Fantasy-Hive

Main Menu

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Interviews
    • Author Spotlight
    • By Author Surname
  • Book Reviews
    • Latest
    • Hive Reads
    • Self-Published
    • By Author Surname
  • Writing
    • Write of Way
    • Worldbuilding By The Numbers
  • Features and Content
    • Ask the Wizard
    • BookTube
    • Busy Little Bees Book Reviews
    • Cover Reveals
    • Cruising the Cosmere
    • Excerpts
    • News and Announcements
    • Original Fiction
      • Four-Part Fiction
    • SPFBO
    • The Unseen Academic
    • Tough Travelling
    • Women In SFF
    • Wyrd & Wonder
  • FAQ

logo

Fantasy-Hive

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Interviews
    • Author Spotlight
    • By Author Surname
  • Book Reviews
    • Latest
    • Hive Reads
    • Self-Published
    • By Author Surname
  • Writing
    • Write of Way
    • Worldbuilding By The Numbers
  • Features and Content
    • Ask the Wizard
    • BookTube
    • Busy Little Bees Book Reviews
    • Cover Reveals
    • Cruising the Cosmere
    • Excerpts
    • News and Announcements
    • Original Fiction
      • Four-Part Fiction
    • SPFBO
    • The Unseen Academic
    • Tough Travelling
    • Women In SFF
    • Wyrd & Wonder
  • FAQ
Book ReviewsFantasyHorrorThe Stephen King Project
Home›Book Reviews›The Stephen King Project – The Talisman (1984)

The Stephen King Project – The Talisman (1984)

By Shona Kinsella
January 30, 2020
2458
3

About the project

I will be reading all of Stephen King’s books in order of publication (with the exception of The Dark Tower series which I will read together, at the end of this adventure) and writing a review of each. I’ll be looking at the recurring themes, the tricks he likes to use, the way he develops character and the way that his craft has evolved in the 44 years since Carrie was first published.

The Talisman is a dark fantasy story that Stephen King co-wrote with Peter Straub, another acclaimed horror writer. On paper, it should be a great book, and again, as someone who loves both fantasy and horror, I would have expected to love it.

The problem is, it’s just not that great.

I’m sure, by now, you understand just how hard it is for me to say that. I guess we all want our heroes to stay on their pedestals, and I love so many of his other books, but this one just left me feeling ‘meh’ – after both times I’ve read it.

The Talisman by Stephen King and Peter StraubThe Talisman tells us the story of Jack Sawyer, a 12-year-old boy with a lot on his mind. His father was killed in a hunting accident a couple of years before the book begins and now his mother has cancer and is clearly dying. Add to that a predatory business partner of his father’s and it’s no wonder Jack is struggling. When he meets Lester ‘Speedy’ Parker and is told that he can go on a grand adventure to save his mother, it’s not really surprising that he jumps at the chance. What I did find surprising, to the point of being unbelievable, was how easily his mother agrees to let him set off on his own to an unknown location for an unknown amount of time…

When Jack was younger, he used to daydream about another place, a cleaner, nicer place. Speedy tells him that not only was this place real, but that he can visit again by ‘flipping’. The Territories, that other place, are a sort of twin to this world and many people from this world have ‘twinners’ over there – people just like them who share their lifeline and moments of import. The Queen, Laura De Loessian, is the twinner of Jack’s mum and she too is dying. Jack has to travel to a place on the other side of the US (and the territories) and retrieve a talisman, which will heal both women.

Sounds interesting, I hear you think. So, what was the problem?

Well, to begin with, I think this book falls down in the area that you can usually rely on King to be on top of his game. I don’t think Jack is a particularly interesting character. Now, we know that King can write great kids – Danny Torrance in The Shining, Tad Trenton in Cujo, the entire cast of IT – so I don’t think the problem is the protagonist’s age. Perhaps it was the cowriting that resulted in such a lacklustre main character, but whatever it was, he didn’t really capture me.

I also felt like this book kind of recycled some of King’s previous characters. Speedy Parker reminds me a lot of Dick Halloran in The Shining. Both of these characters are black, and I fear that King may be relying on stereotypes, however I leave that to someone with more knowledge to judge. Wolf (who is, in my view, the best character in The Talisman) is so much like Tom Cullen from The Stand that I kept expecting him to say ‘M-O-O-N, that spells …’ and Morgan Sloat came very much to remind me of Flagg as he appears in The Stand, especially when Morgan and Jack face off for the final time. I guess over time, it’s to be expected that some recycling of characters will occur, but in this context, it just feels lazy.

My other complaint about this book is the pacing. In my opinion, it is far longer than it had to be. Jack’s journey to the black hotel really drags along at times, with side stories that seem to have little or no bearing on the main plot. This is the first time that I’ve ever felt that the criticism toward King of writing bloated works or being too wordy was accurate. I think this book could have been half the length and carried the plot just as well, if not better. When I was about two-thirds of the way through this book, I received a review copy of Starsight by Brandon Sanderson; if I hadn’t been reading The Talisman for this project, I’m fairly sure I would have put it aside for Starsight since I was struggling.

It really pains me to write a review like this, where I can’t point to any particular thing and say, all that might have been a disappointment, but this bit was really good. It might seem like the problem must be the cowriting, but I have previously read Black House, a sequel to The Talisman, and I found it to be far better.

Have you read The Talisman? What did you think of it? Am I the only one who found it disappointing?

TagsDark FantasyPeter StraubStephen KingThe Talisman

Shona Kinsella

Shona Kinsella is a Scottish fantasy author who lives on the bonnie banks of Loch Lomond with her husband and three children. She is the author of Ashael Rising (Unbound, 2017), Petra McDonald and the Queen of the Fae (Fox Spirit, 2018) and Miranya’s Oath (an illustrated web serial). You can find out more about her work at www.shonakinsella.com and she loves talking to new people on Twitter www.twitter.com/shona_kinsella 

3 comments

  1. Shona 31 January, 2020 at 20:07 Reply

    Bob, I agree, Black House is far superior. I actually read that first, having not realised it was a sequel until I was a good chunk into it and when I finally got around to reading The Talisman, I was so disappointed because Black House had given me such high expectations.

    Sarah, I can understand the DNF. There are definitely elements in there that feel like King to me – Wolf for instance – but yeah, overall it doesn’t feel much like him

  2. Bob 30 January, 2020 at 13:04 Reply

    I remember reading The Talisman during my early King years, when I still felt he could do no wrong, and just feeling sort of ‘meh’ about it. Interesting story, and I love the mythology, but hardly a page-turner. Now, that said, I do think Black House was a far superior sequel and I’ll be first-in-line should they ever follow through on the 3rd book King has previously teased.

  3. Sarah 30 January, 2020 at 11:09 Reply

    I attempted it once and DNF. To me this one never really felt like King in the first place.

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Welcome

Welcome to The Fantasy Hive

We’re a collaborative review site run by volunteers who love Fantasy, Sci-fi, Horror, and everything in-between.

On our site, you can find not only book reviews but author interviews, cover reveals, excerpts from books, acquisition announcements, guest posts by your favourite authors, and so much more.

Have fun exploring…

The Fantasy Hive Team

Visit our shop

Features

Support the Site

Books by A.Z. Anthony/Alex Knight

Books by A.Z. Anthony/Alex Knight

Jeramy’s Books

The Akallian Tales by Jeramy Goble

More from Jonathan

  • Ballad of Black Tom (Feature) The Ballad of Black Tom by Victor LaValle posted on December 6, 2017
  • Book of the New Sun (Feature) The Book of the New Sun by Gene Wolfe posted on November 13, 2017
  • 13 Minutes (Feature) 13 Minutes by Sarah Pinborough posted on December 6, 2017
  • Paper Menagerie (Feature) The Paper Menagerie and Other Stories by Ken Liu posted on December 6, 2017
  • Interview with Steven Erikson posted on November 1, 2018
  • Hex (Feature) HEX by Thomas Olde Heuvelt posted on November 15, 2017
  • Fifth Season (Feature) The Fifth Season by N. K. Jemisin posted on November 14, 2017
  • Binti (Feature) Binti by Nnedi Okorafor posted on November 18, 2017
  • THE DOLORIAD by Missouri Williams (BOOK REVIEW) posted on March 3, 2022
  • MORDEW by Alex Pheby (Book Review) posted on August 6, 2020

Laura’s Books

Books by Laura M. Hughes

More from Laura

  • Malazan Characters: Bridgeburners by Shadaan (Feature) A Beginner’s Guide to Malazan Characters: ‘Gardens of the Moon’ posted 6 years ago
  • The Faithful and the Fallen by John Gwynne 5 Reasons to Read ‘The Faithful and the Fallen’ posted 6 years ago
  • Ruin (Feature) Ruin by John Gwynne posted 6 years ago
  • The Killing Moon (Feature) The Killing Moon by N. K. Jemisin posted 6 years ago
  • Malazan Characters 2 (Feature) A Beginner’s Guide to Malazan Characters: ‘Deadhouse Gates’ posted 6 years ago
  • Prince of Fools (Feature) Prince of Fools by Mark Lawrence posted 6 years ago
  • Larcout (Feature) Larcout by K. A. Krantz posted 6 years ago
  • John Dies at the End (Feature) John Dies at the End by David Wong posted 6 years ago
  • The Emperor's Blades (Feature) The Emperor’s Blades by Brian Staveley posted 6 years ago
  • Slow Regard of Silent Things (Feature) The Slow Regard of Silent Things by Patrick Rothfuss posted 6 years ago